Thursday, March 13, 2008

Smells Like Teen Rebellion

So, as an assignment for class, Amy wanted us to visit mtv.com and watch any of the top videos from 2007 and explain how we could use that video as a text in a media class, especially to focus on gender representations. So I went to watch videos, and as the My Chemical Romance video for "Teenagers" started, I could not focus on gender representations. I sat thinking, "Dimly lit, curtain draped school stage, dancing cheerleaders, a passive audience the erupts into a frenzy and storms the performing space of the band. Smells like an homage, or lack or originality."

As I searched for the Nirvana "Smells Like Teen Spirit" video to make sure the similarities between the two texts was not just the result of an idle imagination, I thought that a more interesting way for me to include this video in a class is as a comparison. Both videos use similar motifs and the songs lyrically discuss teenage isolation, celebrates being misunderstood, and has an underlying anger and drive. The songs and videos were made for different generations (todays teens were in diapers or in utero when Nirvana's video appeared) and I think an interesting activity would be to explore how each video envisions teen rebellion.

We can start with the cheerleaders. In both videos, we see shots of suggetive dancing, but the sexuality is counteracted by the appearance of the girls. Anarchy symbols, stringy hair and tattoos on the Nirvana crew, gas masks for My Chemical Romance. The student audience in Nirvana's video was made up of hair thrashing, flannel-clad slackers. The audience in the "Teenagers" video are students that look like those that could be seen in mainstream magazine clothing advertisements. The band and music spoke for itself in the 1990s; today, heavy-handed moments like images of mushroom clouds and batons used as machine guns leadenly drive home the message. The lighting in Nirvana's videos obscures the action, Kurt Cobain's face is not really seen. The lighting in My Chemical Romance's world is less extreme, the face of the lead singer is a selling point of the appeal of the band. It seems that rebellion has been mainstreamed in the last 15 years.


But is that just me? I think it would be interesting to show the two videos to see if the students noticed the differences and similarities I did. Why is the 2007 video cast, directed, and designed the way it is? Which is more effective in appealing to teen audiences today? Which is more effective in embracing rebellion? What was My Chemical Romance hoping to achieve by taking Nirvana's ideas? What did they add to it? Where are they less successful?

I fear that today's audiences may look at Nirvana's work and squirm at the thought of sweaty, smelly grungers slamming into and crawling on top of each other. They would rather share a stage with My Chemical Romance, I expect. What has changed? The teen or the spirit?

Oh, and we could examine the gender representations.


Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Race Boundaries?



In discussing race in a media class, this photo may be a place to start. I noticed it first in Entertainment Weekly, where the article challenged readers to guess who is playing the character in the center of this photo, a production still from the Ben Stiller's new film Tropic Thunder. The actor is Robert Downey, Jr. and the film is a Hollywood satire.

Students know Ben Stiller and Jack Black and are familiar with their respective comedic approaches. The question to pose: is the fact that Robert Downey, Jr. is a white actor playing a character who has been cast in a role written for a black actor, so he decides to "play it black" worth noting or discussing? Hollywood used to embrace casting white actors in a variety of ethnic roles, but that approach was frowned on for a time, at least in terms of ethnicity. Should there be rules and should the rules apply to just ethnic backgrounds, or also to gender, sexuality, religion?

A quote from Downey in EW: "If it's done right, it could be the type of role you called Peter Sellers to do 35 years ago. If you don't do it right, we're going to hell." What is the protocol that youth audiences accept in terms of actors playing beyond their own cultures? Jim Emerson's blog, Scanners, explores the history of this practice in the media:


OK, we've also seen a black actor playing a racist white man who turns black overnight (Godfrey Cambridge in Melvin Van Peebles' 1970 "Watermelon Man"); a white male actor playing a white female actor (Dustin Hoffman in "Tootsie"); a white female American actor playing a male Chinese-Australian "dwarf" (Linda Hunt, "The Year of Living Dangerously"); a black male actor playing various white, female, Chinese and other characters (Eddie Murphy, "Coming to America," "Norbit"); a white woman playing a white male pre-op transsexual passing as a white woman (Felicity Huffman, "Transamerica"); a straight white woman playing a gay white female-impersonator (Julie Andrews, "Victor/Victoria"); a German-Japanese-Venezuelan male actor playing a Kenyan-white male American senator and presidential candidate (Fred Armisen on "Saturday Night Live" as Barack Obama)

While watching an episode of Law & Order, I noticed that at one point the character played by Ice-T is classified as a black man by one individual and as a white man by another. The character played by Adam Beach is called a Mexican, which he laughs off. Our race, ethnicity, and culture define us, but should they also limit us? Another posting on the Scanners blog reprints an empassioned letter from Nicholas Rizzo who examines why he responded so powerfully to the film No Country for Old Men. As a part of the letter he suggests that the Mexican drug runners function as "stark stereotypes" whereas the character played by Javier Bardem was complex and compelling. He throws off a parenthetical aside that struck me powerfully as I contemplated these issues:

I sometimes wonder if our society views multi-racial people as the most beautiful because, if we cannot determine which racial group they belong to, no racial stereotypes are attached and then we see their beauty purely and unencumbered.

Do we classify? Should we classify? How should "colorblind casting" look? How true do we need to be? Which boundaries can be crossed as actors?

So, let's look at the photo and see how the students respond. The hope is that they will come up with as powerful and as conflicting of views that I have stumbled on over the past week. It is the complexity of this issue that intrigues me. I just don't hope that they do not expect any easy answers from me.

Friday, March 7, 2008

Men and Women and Hot Breakfast Bars

This week, as we were discussing gender representations in media, I came across a story about a new advertsing campaign by Holiday Inn Express. The article was on Slate.com. It was in the site's Ad Report Card section. I enjoy hitting this section every few weeks because my television viewing could be classified as sparse, and the television I do see on a regular basis (local news and syndicated shows) often do not have the big national ads on them.

Plus, I enjoy the writing in the ad report card section. It has helped me to understand the choices made in putting together an ad campaign, its desired affect, and its actual affect, according to Seth Stevens.

In the article found here, Stevens discusses how men are represented and how they may respond to the new Hot Breakfast Bar ads. More interesting, however, is the ad in the same campaign that features women as the central characters. Both ads are the same length, with the same message on the same set. The differences come in the characters, the storyline, and the humor. I believe that this could be a great curricular support for gender representations in a media literacy unit. The portrayals are not overtly sexual, so students can examine gender representations beyond the common ones in ads targeting teens and young adults. Students could be asked to express the central idea of each, the target audience, and how the message is presented.

This posting in Slate also made mention of the SportCenter ads. These ads, abundant on YouTube, could also be examined in a classroom environment to determine why they appeal to men, their target audience. I don't think that my wife ever really appreciated them, and she probably rolled her eyes when I would stop mid-conversation to watch whenever I happened to catch one. Just thinking about them now brings a smile to my XY chromosome face.

It was handy having both ads in the same article, and handy that this article was posted on a week when we focused on gender in Amy's class. But, I also encourage regular reading of this feature for those teachers who teach media. It is very readable and can bring lots of ideas about how advertising can be analyzed for its form, content, and effectiveness. Enjoy a future with Seth Stevens.

As a post script, I, too, grinned at the "Cinnamon roll? That's something you send your sister!" line. (Insert SportCenter theme here).

Sunday, February 24, 2008

Media and Community


Over the past couple of weeks, I have tried to explain why my one year as a film major ended with a transfer to theatre education. This weekend, had anyone been by my side, they would have had an understanding beyond my stated excuse, "All we did in the film program was sit in silence in the dark, watch movies, and write papers."
My production at the high school, Cyrano de Bergerac, opened on Friday night. It has not been an easy production. It was a very large cast (30+), which has it own difficulties (managing schedules and needs of 30+ people), but it is also a difficult show for high school actors - the language, the swordplay, the elevated emotions. My schedule did not help my stress in pulling it all together, and I figured that if I could just get it behind me, I would be happy. I believed that the cast had done a good job, but I might have been too close to it. And, how many people in our community would be interested in a 19th Century French play? I didn't know what to expect.
But then we opened. We had a larger than expected house on Friday, especially considering we conflicted with state girl's basketball. The actors took hold of the show and ran. And the audience was right with them. I sat and watched what these teenage actors did to capture the grand emotions of Romanticism and a crowd of children, teens, and adults was rapt with what would happen next. It was a show that I had never seen in rehearsal. Everyone in that auditorium contributed to a successful production. It was even better on Saturday night. And I realized that it is the vitality of theatre that won me. In the end, maybe 700 will have seen the show. It will only exist for those two hours each night, and then in the memories of those involved. But the memory will be there because they all contributed.
I remember plays I saw as a child in Montana (my Gram took me to West Side Story, my mom to King Lear), and they stay with me more than films of my childhood. Bazin equated film with embalming. Theatre does not embalm, it resurrects a text. I have not had a media experience as visceral as any theatre experience, and I don't know if I can.
On YouTube, you can track views, you can post and read comments, you can parody or respond with your own work, but still it does not have the community that I have experienced in theatre. Media can be collaborative, but mediation places a distance between creator and audience. As I sat with a smile on my face, watching my students understand the text better than they ever had before because of the audience's reactions (Wait, that is funny! Whoa, this moment really is heartbreaking.), I could see whay these students devoted so many hours to it, why over a hundred students auditioned to be in it. Film started by replicating theatrical conventions, but soon found its own language. Theatrical conventions cannot survive on film. It does not work. In the reading for Sharon's class there are theorists who discuss how media are losing their individual identifiers and becoming more alike. But new media is not like this weekend with hundreds of people breathing the same air and sharing a story.
So, I am happy, and I hope my students are, too. We have one night to go, which hopefully will be as great as what they have already done. We can talk about community, and phenomonology, and interaction with media, but untimately it pales to theatre. Maybe not forever, and not for eveyone, but at least for me now. I can use this comparison in my theatre classes to talk about how new media is trying to capture the communal theatrical experience and see if students have had media experiences like unto theatre. It will be interesting to see if their perceptions are similar to mine, or having been raised on new media, if they view those experiences as more communal than theatre for them. If they feel that the experience is similar or greater to being in a live production or the audience of one, I will be sad, but it will link new media and theatre more in my mind, where a rift now exists.

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Saving Ebert's Hide

I am a film teacher who rarely goes to the movies. This can be tricky because my students all assume that if I teach film, I need to have seen everything. But my schedule does not really allow me to see films in the theatre. I manage to get a little caught up on DVD in the summer, but end up seeing only a small fraction of new films each year. Instead, I read about film. I have a list of Web sites and magazines I read on a weekly basis to have knowledge about pretty much any film in current release. At least then I can talk intelligently about films when my students bring them up in class. For me, I read enough other people’s opinion’s to understand the film and filmmaker, but belatedly form any opinion of my own when and if I happen to see the film.

My students are the opposite. They see film all the time and rarely read anything, other than celebrity tabloid press, about films. Their opinion is all that matters. I do an informal survey in my classes about if they every read any critical responses to film. Most major newspapers and magazines have film reviewers on staff, I state, is this just wasted money? The answer appears to be yes. I have maybe one, seldom two students in a class who read any critical response to film. The film critic, they say, is dying.

This didn’t concern me much. My students are of another generation. It is all about them. They are not film geeks, like me, who lap up the words of Roger Ebert with delight (his nearly year-long hiatus due to health problems was a black time for me). So, my focus in the class has been to explore the opinions of the students. I tell them, their opinion is what matters. For the first paper of the semester, I require them to find a professional, critical review of the film they are writing on and comment on their opinion of the reviewer’s opinion. This has never been very successful. Often, they find rambling musings on a blog somewhere that usually support the student’s views, or that just have a plot synopsis and do not explore the film critically at all. I shrug when I read their papers. “It is about the student’s opinions,” I tell myself.

This semester was different. Frustrated by the quality of the reviews students include with their papers, and suspecting that they only skim the review anyway and say, in the most general terms, I agree/disagree with this reviewer, I showed the students what film criticism could be. I hooked the projector up to my computer and pulled up some professional reviews that we examined as a class. I looked at Ebert’s review of Cloverfield. He was direct in stating what worked and didn’t for him in the film, and since his critique was so pointed, the students could respond to what he was saying. His views fell pretty much in line with the majority of the class, which surprised them. Hearing parents and other adults talk about the film had led the students to think that adults “just didn’t get it.” Ebert didn’t mind the “queasy-cam” style of shooting the film, and thought it supported how the story was being told. Students talked about the plusses and minuses of the hand-held style. Ebert discounted complaints that too many questions about the monster were left unanswered. Students on both sides of the issue stated their feelings. All of a sudden, movie critics were not old, stuffy people who slammed everything good. They were people who loved movies and got to share their opinions with others for a paycheck. And sometimes, according to the students, the critics were right.

For the evaluation papers turned in by this new group, the students explored the opinions of others to a degree that they hadn’t in papers before. They sometimes quoted multiple reviewers. In comparing their views with others, the students become more solidified on the impact that a film had (or did not have) on them. One student quoted the Entertainment Weekly cover story that dealt with Juno and discussed how the character was more than the center of the film, but a real model to female teens. They started looking at a film through someone else’s eyes. I usually get my students there by the end of the semester, and it is mostly as a result of listening to their classmates discuss film. With the reviews, they crossed geographic, gender, economic, and generational lines. They came closer to seeing films the way I do on a weekly basis. If only I could come closer to seeing films, so I could add my response to the mix, like my newbie film students are doing right now. I will be adding Ebert, et al, to more of my lessons and watch the students open their eyes. Maybe I can still save the professional film reviewer.

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Daddy's Little Girl

It was Valentine’s Day this week. My two sons love the holiday. My two-year-old daughter is not quite sure what it is all about. The boys brought home bags of valentine’s from school and sat on the floor reading their cards, laughing at the puns, sharing and comparing. Isabel watched and grabbed a valentine from their pile and carried it around until it was crumpled and mangled.

Now, my kids are not as pop culture savvy as many of their peers. They looked blankly at several of the valentines not knowing who was on the card. They know who SpongeBob is but don’t realize that he lives in a pineapple under the sea. They can name Spiderman though they have never seen him in action. They have a strong connection with Scooby Doo and are well-versed in the original 1970s episodes, and I am okay with that. Isabel is even less knowledgable, but she knew what she wanted. The valentine she carried around all day? Bratz.

Now, I have no idea what Bratz are or what they do. I just know that they have big, make-up coated eyes and dress in a way that puts them just past Betty Boop on the skank scale. Isabel had no context for the character. I imagine she was just responding to the color, the design, and layout of the card. But that is where consumerism starts, isn’t it? I smiled when she kept asking for her Disney Princess pajamas when she had no idea who those girls were on her tummy. But it wasn’t until the Bratz card that I really considered how those characters were ingratiating themselves with my children. It seems like a tough time to be growing up as a media seeped girl. I read an article in Entertainment Weekly (see my next post) about the popularity of Juno, and one person suggested that Juno’s success was partially driven by the fact that teen girls now have a cultural icon on the same plane as Holden Caufield. She acts on her own terms. But isn’t that how they are marketing Bratz and the Disney Princesses? I will be honest with you, I would be just fine if my daughter decided that she wanted to get some turtle necks and some square glasses and be like Velma when she grows up. Velma is smart. She is independent. She has her own slang (“Jinkies!”). And, she is all but ignored by Fred. What more could a father want?

My daughter is not media literate. She cannot see past the packaging to discern the contents. I need to work on that. I cannot just examine these issues in my classroom. But this event made me really consider the mindset of my students. They were two-year-olds influenced by forces they could not understand. Where do they stand now?

Friday, February 15, 2008

A Night in the Car

On Wednesday night, I was driving home from Provo. I had attended class that evening and while I was taking a midterm, a blizzard was burying nothern Utah County. My wife suggested that I spend the night in Orem, but I had started north and the roads were clear and traffic light. That is until I got to Lehi. The final ten miles of my commute took just over three hours. Hundreds of cars sitting in idle. I had turned on the radio to get a traffic report as I headed home, but KSL had chosen to not disrupt the BYU basketball game broadcast to tell listeners that, well, that hundreds of acres of highways and freeways had been jammed with immobile vehicles. I longed for news and was frustrated by not having instantaneous access to it. I called my wife, but was wary of using the phone and "driving" even though I was not moving. Finally, about 9:45 PM, after having spent an hour not moving and being a couple of hours away from home, KSL started a live broadcast fielding calls and text messages from those in the same boat as I, some who had been stuck since 5 PM. Listening did not move me any faster (my shaky knowledge of Lehi surface streets and frontage roads helped a bit there), but it did pass time, and it bonded me to all of those in my same predicament. I marveled that there were no calls or texts of anger, rage, or frustration. There was acceptance. There was humor. There was a desire to pass information and encouragement to others. By having a media outlet, I presume, tension was dispelled. I felt the same way. I wasn't something that was happening to me anymore. It was happening to us. I am glad I could vent occassionally to my wife, but at 10:30, when I encouraged her to go to bed, I was left with the miles and miles of strangers. And with the texts and voices of those strangers.

While teaching on Thursday, I talked to a couple of students who were stuck in that massive jam coming back from state wrestling and club volleyball. They were not a part of KSL's demographic and did not join that same community I did. They did have phones and called and texted friends. For about 30 minutes, I was beside a UTA bus. Those on the bus did not commune face to face. They sat solemn and frustrated. If they had a mediated means to deal with it, perhaps they would have been in a better mind set.

This is a great example of the power of media for those students who were stuck as I was. I don't think that those who did not experience it would understand the power of sharing the experience through the radio that night. It is a great example I can use, and try to find moments when my students had similar experiences.

My favorite moment on the radio was when the announcer kept repeatedly admonishing listeners who were in their homes to not leave their homes and contribute to the traffic mess. I could not help but wonder, "Who leaves their homes at 11:00 PM on a snowy Wednesday night just for the hell of it?"